Best Pizza in Chattanooga: 7 Pizzerias Worth Every Slice (2026)

From wood-fired Neapolitan at Community Pie to 22-inch NYC slabs at Goodfellas Pizzeria, these are the Chattanooga pizza spots that locals actually go back to.

Chattanooga punches above its weight when it comes to pizza. For a mid-sized city in the Tennessee Valley, the options are genuinely good - and spread across enough neighborhoods that wherever you are, a great pie is close by. You can get wood-fired Neapolitan in Miller Plaza, a 22-inch New York slab by the slice downtown, a carefully sourced thin-crust on Broad Street, or a creative hop-forward pub pizza with a cold craft beer. These are the spots worth knowing about.

1. Community Pie - 850 Market St

Community Pie sits in Miller Plaza near the heart of downtown, and it earned its reputation honestly. The wood-fired Neapolitan pizzas come out of the oven with the right amount of char on the crust - blistered and chewy in the right places without going stiff. But what makes Community Pie stand out is that they also do New York-style pies, so you can go full Neapolitan traditionalist or grab something built more like a classic slice.

The bar is solid, with a good craft beer selection and homemade gelato for dessert courtesy of Milk & Honey. The vibe is relaxed and neighborhood-y despite being downtown - exposed brick, warm lighting, the kind of place that works for a date or a casual Tuesday dinner. They have a second location out at Hamilton Place if you're on the east side of town.

If you're new to the Chattanooga pizza scene and need a single starting point, Community Pie is it.

2. Lupi's Pizza Pies - 406 Broad St

Lupi's has been feeding Chattanooga since 1996, which makes it the closest thing the city has to a hometown pizza institution. The flagship location on Broad Street is a little eclectic - colorful decor, arcade games in the back, an open kitchen feel - and the pizza is the thin-crust, hand-tossed style that's become Lupi's signature over the past three decades.

What sets Lupi's apart ingredient-wise is Flying Turtle Farms, the operation's own pizza farm that supplies fresh produce. That's a genuine commitment to sourcing that you don't see often. The menu covers a lot of ground: 30-plus topping combinations, calzones, lasagna, salads, and both gluten-free and vegan options. Prices are slightly higher than a chain but justified by what's on the plate.

Lupi's now has five locations across Chattanooga, Cleveland, and Ooltewah, so there's likely one near wherever you're staying.

3. Goodfellas Pizzeria - 1208 King St

Goodfellas leans hard into the New York identity and makes it work. Their pizzas come in at 22 inches - proper NYC dimensions - with dough made fresh daily, hand-tossed, and baked on stone. The slices are big and foldable, the cheese-to-sauce ratio is on point, and the crust has that pull-apart quality that serious pizza people look for.

The King Street location adds some personality with the Wiseguy Lounge, a speakeasy-themed bar downstairs that does craft cocktails. For lunch, they run a $10 special that's hard to argue with. Monday nights bring half-price 12-inch pizzas. If you're downtown and want something unpretentious and filling, Goodfellas is the call.

4. Wooden City - 203 Broad St

Wooden City operates closer to the upscale end of downtown dining, but the wood-fired pizza holds its own as the reason to go. The pies come out of the oven with real heat and good smoke, and the toppings lean toward interesting combinations rather than defaults - blistered peppers, quality charcuterie, things that suggest someone's actually paying attention to the menu.

The overall setting is sleek and modern, with a full kitchen program beyond just pizza. If you're pairing dinner with cocktails or want a place that works for a business dinner or a night out, Wooden City earns a spot on the list. The location on Broad Street puts you in the center of downtown action.

You can browse Wooden City on NoogaFinder for hours and more details.

5. Mellow Mushroom - 205 Broad St

The Mellow Mushroom on Broad Street is the downtown location and has the full chain experience with some local personality baked in. The appeal here is in the creative toppings and the breadth of dietary options - a large portion of their menu works for gluten-free and vegan diners, which matters more than ever in 2026. The crust is thicker than a Neapolitan pie but not as dense as deep dish - it sits somewhere in between and works well with heavier topping combinations.

The downtown location has a college-town energy with good beer options and a private event space. It's reliable in a way that chains often aren't. There's also a second location at Hamilton Place near the mall on the east side if you're coming from that direction.

6. Southside Pizza - Southside Historic District

Southside Pizza keeps it New York and keeps it simple: hand-tossed pies, slices by the piece, calzones, and sandwiches. No gimmicks, no identity crisis. They're in the Southside Historic District, which puts them in one of Chattanooga's most walkable and interesting neighborhoods - close to galleries, live music venues, and the independent retail that's made Southside one of the more vibrant parts of the city.

Going for a slice after walking around Southside is a natural move. The pizza is straightforward and good - the kind of place that prioritizes doing the basics correctly over expanding a complicated menu. Hours run Tuesday through Sunday with later closes on Friday and Saturday, so it's also a solid post-bar option.

7. TailGate Brewery - 1464 Market St

TailGate is primarily known as a brewery, but the pizza at the Market Street location is good enough to earn a spot on this list. The Nashville-based brand brought a solid kitchen to Southside, and the combination of legit pizza with a deep, rotating beer list makes it a natural destination. Sit on the patio when the weather cooperates and order a pie with whatever's on tap that sounds interesting - it's one of the better ways to spend an evening in that part of town.

You can check out TailGate Brewery on NoogaFinder for the latest hours and details.

What to Know Before You Go

A few practical notes for navigating the Chattanooga pizza scene:

Downtown concentration: Community Pie, Lupi's, Goodfellas, Wooden City, and Mellow Mushroom are all within a short walk of each other along or near Broad Street and Market Street. If you're staying downtown, you're in good shape.
Southside options: Southside Pizza and TailGate Brewery both sit in the Southside Historic District, which makes for a natural evening - browse the neighborhood, then settle in for pizza and a beer.
Monday deals: Goodfellas does half-price 12-inch pizzas on Mondays. If you're in town mid-week, that's worth knowing.
Dietary options: Lupi's and Mellow Mushroom both have well-developed gluten-free and vegan menus. Community Pie also has gluten-free options.

Frequently Asked Questions

What's the best pizza in downtown Chattanooga?

Community Pie at 850 Market St is consistently ranked among the best, with wood-fired Neapolitan pies and a solid bar program. Lupi's on Broad Street and Goodfellas on King Street are close runners-up depending on whether you want thin-crust or New York-style.

Is there good New York-style pizza in Chattanooga?

Yes. Goodfellas Pizzeria on King Street does proper 22-inch NYC-style pies with daily fresh dough. Southside Pizza in the Southside Historic District also does NY-style by the slice and whole pie.

Are there gluten-free pizza options in Chattanooga?

Several spots offer gluten-free crusts, including Lupi's Pizza Pies, Mellow Mushroom, and Community Pie. Call ahead to confirm current availability at your preferred location.

What's a good pizza spot for a date night in Chattanooga?

Community Pie works well for a date night - warm atmosphere, good wine and beer list, and the wood-fired pizza makes for a satisfying meal without being too heavy. Wooden City is another option if you want something a bit more upscale. For more ideas, check out our Chattanooga date night guide.